All comments sections automatically close 14 days after the story has published. For more details, please see our discussion guidelines.
1 month ago
And
just why would the police stop someone wearing an exercise weight vest
of some forty pounds on the public street of an urban area. golly, that
would be like you know, stopping a teenager on high school grounds
carrying a gun case? Huh. When will this police harassment stop? When?
Now if the police had entered the gym to stop a person wearing an exercise weight vest while on the treadmill, ....
2 months ago
Apparently,
this is progress for the Post. Now we can find out what men who were
formerly women feel about how they are treated. Next, hopefully will be
an article asking men who have always been men, how they feel about how
they are treated. But, then I note the article bashing Jordan Peterson,
so I guess one step forward, two steps back.
2 months ago
I
just checked the front page for the site they appear to be running
three stories about how white men feel they are being treated, not
counting all the stories about white, male politicians complaining about
how people misunderstand that fact that they're just trying to do their
best to do God's work. Stories:
Great article. These are meaningful real life stories that deserve to be heard, so we can all understand better.
2 months ago
The fact it takes trans men accounts of being a man to even talk about male issues show how much contempt society has for men.
2 months ago
"The
first act of violence that patriarchy demands of males is not violence
toward women. Instead patriarch demands of all males that they engage in
acts of psychic self-mutilation, that they kill of the emotional parts
of themselves. If an individual is not successful in emotionally
crippling himself, he can count on patriarchal men to enact rituals of
power that will assault his self esteem."
-- bell hooks, noted feminist writer and social activist.
2 months ago
One
of the most disappointing things to me about Sense8 the Wachovski
Sisters series on Netflx was how they portrayed women. They had a very
unique opportunity to share something they alone had experienced and
still their story was about men with women in weak and supporting roles.
Please don't tell me how you've felt like a woman all of your life then
write a series that clearly says you have not and even now that you are
a woman you don't understand what means to be one. And don't get me
started on Bruce Jenner. I'm sorry for the Trans community that that
person is many people's first experience with Trans people.
2 months ago
life
has worked out well for these four, however, each is clearly
intelligent and educated and so their success likely would have happened
either way. what about the regret held be a large number of trans
people, mainly transwomen that found the grass was not greener,
personal acceptance was the number 1 barrier and careers stagnated or
disappeared. I know two such people living such an
existence. this article was quite heart-warming about these four
success stories; where is the article about regret, angst, depression
and suicide?
2 months ago
This
was a really interesting article. I imagine the more people
interviewed, the more varied the responses would be, and it would be
enlightening to hear more. I was struck by what Chris said about
directness and asking directly for things. The reality is that
there are usually subtle repercussions when women are direct, either in
expressing opinions or in asking for something. I have found this
to be true whether I am dealing with men or women. Men's ideas are
more readily accepted and carefully considered generally, and using
directness can work against women when it comes to expressing
ideas. Ask any woman how many times she has expressed an idea, had
it dismissed, and later accepted when it is presented either by a man
or by a woman who carefully plays the game of dancing nicely around the
subject first.
2 months ago
I
think that this article brought up a lot of issues that men deal with
that I wish were talked about more in society. While I'm glad that trans
men got to share their experiences, I wish that the media would be just
as willing talk about those same experiences that cis men face. There
is a notion in society that men are privileged in every situation and
can't possibly be disadvantaged in any way, which is clearly false to
anyone willing to actually think about society at large.
There
were four parts to this article that I especially identified with. First
the fact that if a female student is showing inappropriate interest in a
teacher, it is laughed off, and the fact that any lies the female
student tells about him could get him fired. My father, a lawyer, has a
female staff member in the room when interviewing children, which I
doubt a female lawyer would worry about. Second, the fact that society
deems it okay for women to make male bashing remarks (like the woman on
the phone in the story) when any man would be harshly criticized for
doing the same. Third, the way society acts like men who offer advice to
their friend who is having a problem are somehow doing it worse than
women who just offer sympathy (when the reverse is really true). Fourth,
the way society is more forgiving of women who lash out, while saying
that there is "no excuse" for male violence even if he has suffered
trauma.
We need to do better as a society on these issues. Women aren't the only ones who face gender issues.
2 months ago
(Edited)
In fact I would even argue that men's gender issues cause many of women's as well as the reverse.
2 months ago
I
fear that most people will take the experiences of these 4 people and
generalize it to the entire male/female population - which is probably a
mistake. 4 people are not representative of any population, male,
female, black, white, etc. I will note the exception of the black
person though since we already have plenty of accounts of police being
more suspicious of black men.
2 months ago
Interesting...
I wonder why Chris assumed his ability to assert himself in his career
more effectively was because he was happier, not because his assertions
were more acceptable. My experience does not show that to be true. All
very interesting and thought provoking. Really thought Zander's
experience of racial bias was important for all of us to realize, I have
seen that in action among black friends of mine and it is tough to
accept its prevalence. Zander's experience of being outside the
camaraderie loop with other women not familiar with him was probably
quite true (for both sexes). Funny how much we all judge and are judged
and how it keeps us separated and probably more dysfunctional as a
society.
2 months ago
Yes about Zander. That was very powerful and should be raised loudly.
Comments are now closed
All comments sections automatically close 14 days after the story has published. For more details, please see our discussion guidelines.
Now if the police had entered the gym to stop a person wearing an exercise weight vest while on the treadmill, ....
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/national/wp/2018/07/23/feature/a-father-a-daughter-and-the-search-for-answers-in-a-toxic-town/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/im-a-sheriff-dont-flood-this-country-with-3d-printed-guns/2018/07/26/38d9a9b8-9052-11e8-b769-e3fff17f0689_story.html
https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/post-partisan/wp/2018/07/26/sorry-brock-turner-outercourse-is-not-a-viable-defense/
-- bell hooks, noted feminist writer and social activist.
There were four parts to this article that I especially identified with. First the fact that if a female student is showing inappropriate interest in a teacher, it is laughed off, and the fact that any lies the female student tells about him could get him fired. My father, a lawyer, has a female staff member in the room when interviewing children, which I doubt a female lawyer would worry about. Second, the fact that society deems it okay for women to make male bashing remarks (like the woman on the phone in the story) when any man would be harshly criticized for doing the same. Third, the way society acts like men who offer advice to their friend who is having a problem are somehow doing it worse than women who just offer sympathy (when the reverse is really true). Fourth, the way society is more forgiving of women who lash out, while saying that there is "no excuse" for male violence even if he has suffered trauma.
We need to do better as a society on these issues. Women aren't the only ones who face gender issues.